Others seem to prefer I dream of Jeannie
typed for your pleasure on 23 March 2025, at 1.00 pmSdtrk: ‘Carpet rash’ by Total control
This is something I’ve been spending far too much time thinking about: Here are two completely unsolicited observations concerning the popular American Sixties sitcom Bewitched, that originally aired on broadcast telly from 1964 to 1972, and has been enjoying multiple reruns via syndication and streaming services to this day. If you’re not familiar with the premise of the programme, it is a lighthearted look at the life of Samantha and Darrin Stephens, a married couple living in suburbia. The conceit is that Darrin is a human man whose spouse Samantha is a witch, and eight series of wacky occult/spooky hijinks ensued.

Now the part of Samantha’s goofball doofus bellend dipshit of a husband, Darrin Stephens, was portrayed by Dick York for six years, and then he was played by Dick Sargent for the rest of the show’s run when York’s longstanding back injury got too much for him to mitigate. Now although the actors look somewhat similar, if you stare at them long enough, you’ll eventually notice that they’re actually two different blokes. As continuity was barely a thing in Sixties television, no explanation was given to the audience as to why Berenstain Darrin was suddenly replaced with Berenstein Darrin until years later.
My question is: given the loathing that Samantha’s mother Endora had for her human son-in-law, why didn’t they write an episode where Darrin simply went too far in pushing Endora’s buttons, leading her to cast a spell on him to change his face? Subsequent scripts could’ve gone one of two ways with it — either for a couple of series into the programme, Darrin could’ve been repeatedly convincing everyone who knew him that he was the same Darrin, to varying degrees of success, OR, York could’ve become Sargent, and none of the other characters would’ve noticed, except for maybe one person. Probably that nosey Mrs Kravitz. Yes, I’m well aware that I’m expecting too much out of an American sitcom made in the mid-Sixties, but come on.
Incidentally, I always found it to be a weird coincidence, especially when I was younger, that the two actors playing Darrin were both named Dick. To be honest, it was confusing for years, and it still trips me up on the occasions that I find myself thinking about Bewitched (not often, really) to this day. ‘Was Sargent the first one, or was it York??’ You know.
It reminds me of how I used to believe that Roger, John, and Andy Taylor in Duran Duran were all related. They aren’t! Even the band’s keyboardist and style icon Nick Rhodes jokingly admitted in a video interview one time that he has no idea how that happened! A surplus of Taylors, a bellyful of Dicks.
One of the more memorable aspects of Bewitched is that whenever Samantha cast a spell, she wiggled her nose, which was accompanied by a specific musical sting that was probably played on a xylophone. It’s pretty damned cute. My other question is: when the producers were casting the actress who would eventually be Samantha, were they looking to cast a woman who could twitch her nose, or did they cast Elizabeth Montgomery, find out later that she could twitch her nose, and worked that into Samantha’s character traits? Cos what are the odds, really?
Yup! That’s all I got. As an aside, Bewitched was popular in multiple countries, particularly Japan, where the show was renamed 奥さまは魔女 (Okusama wa majou, or My wife is a witch), and in 1967, shoujo mangaka Masako Watanabe drew a manga adaptation for the publication Weekly Margaret that lasted nine chapters. You can check out a scanlation version of one of those chapters right here!
I suppose I could draw a line under this post and say Samantha was a delight, but ultimately I’m more drawn to her sassy brunette cousin, Serena, as portrayed by Pandora Spocks.
Whatever happened to Pandora, anyway? Tarantino should revitalise her career by casting her in something. And what were the odds of her looking almost exactly like Elizabeth Montgomery?? (see below)

Random similar posts, for more timewasting:
Was this really worth writing down? on May 11th, 2006
Awkward, but fascinating! But awkward on August 23rd, 2008